BY JOHN PERLIN April 10, 2014
Few inventions in the history of Bell Laboratories evoked as much media attention and public excitement as the silicon solar cell, known at the time as the Bell Solar Battery. The details about this invention that Bell disclosed at the press conference the company held in April 1954 greatly boosted interest in solar energy.
John Yellott, a mechanical engineer who probably knew more about twentieth-century attempts to use the sun’s energy than anyone else in America, hailed the silicon solar cell as “the first really important breakthrough in solar energy technology” for that time period.1
In fact, according to a 1955 Newsweek report, many foresaw the solar cell’s “development as an eventual competitor to atomic power.”2
Technical Progress Continues in the Lab
Technical progress continued, and in the next eighteen months cell efficiency doubled. But commercial success eluded solar cells because of their prohibitive cost. With a 1-watt cell costing $286, Chapin calculated that in 1956 a home-owner would have to pay $1,430,000 for an array of sufficient size to power the average house. This led him to the sober assessment that, “however exciting the prospect is of using silicon solar converters for power,…clearly, we have not advanced to where we can compete…commercially.”3
Hoffman Electronics, owner of the license to commercialize the Bell solar cell, begged to differ. CEO Leslie Hoffman saw its future in powering electrical devices in areas distant from electrical lines. “Consider,” he told a gathering of government officials, “a remote telephone repeater station in the middle of the desert….An array of solar cells and a system of storage batteries is the answer….Either heavy expendable dry batteries or fuel for a rather unreliable gasoline-engine charging unit has to be packed in to the site at great expense. The solar cell,” he emphasized, full of conviction, “is a much better answer.”4
The Silicon Atomic Battery Temporarily Eclipses the Bell Invention
These officials, like most Americans, however, saw their salvation in a different type of independent power system — the atomic battery. RCA, Bell Laboratories’ rival, had come up with a nuclear-run silicon cell, hoping for a perfect fit with America’s emerging infatuation with the atom. Instead of using sun- supplied photons, the atomic battery allegedly ran on photons emitted from strontium 90, one of the deadliest radioactive materials.
RCA made a dramatic presentation at its Radio City headquarters in Manhattan: David Sarnoff, founder and president of RCA, whose initial claim to fame was being the telegraph operator who had tapped to the world: “the titanic has sunk,” hit the keys of a facsimile powered by the atomic battery to send the message “atoms for peace.”5
What RCA did not tell the public was why the venetian blinds had to be closed during Sarnoff ’s telegraphy. Years later one of the lead scientists in the atomic-battery project revealed RCA’s dirty little secret: had the silicon device been exposed to the sun’s rays that afternoon, solar energy would have overpowered the strontium 90. And if the strontium 90 had been removed, the battery would have continued to work on solar power alone! The director of RCA Laboratories didn’t mince words when he ordered his scientists to comply with the ruse, telling them, “Who cares about solar energy? Look, what we have is atomic energy at work. That’s the big thing that’s going to catch the attention of the public, the press, the scientific community,” despite the fact that the Bell Solar Battery outperformed its atomic rival by a factor of 1 million.6
And right he was. The government persuaded Americans, with the help of the media, to dream of the day when their homes, cars, locomotives, and even airplanes would run on radioactive waste produced by nuclear reactors. The Illustrated London News chimed in, calling the atomic battery “a revolutionary invention which in time may have as far-reaching an effect as [Michael] Faraday’s” discovery of the means to generate electricity.7 With this in mind, who needed the sun? Alas, powering novelty items such as toys and transistor radios turned out to be the Bell Solar Battery’s only commercial success.
Martin Wolf, one of the first scientists devoted to photovoltaic work, recalled a company display “where under room lighting…[toy] ships traveled in circles in a children’s wading pool. The model of a DC-4 with four electric-motors… turning the propellers was powered exclusively by the solar cell embedded in the wings.”8 With the Bell Solar Battery used solely for playthings, much of the initial enthusiasm generated by the Bell discovery soon waned.
The Bell Solar Battery Finds Its Place in the Sun
How could Chapin, depressed by this turn of events, help but wonder, “What to do with our new baby?”9
A colleague at Bell Laboratories, Gordon Raisbeck, did not share Chapin’s pessimism. He wrote, “Very likely the solar battery will find its greatest usefulness in doing jobs the need for which we have not felt.”10 Dr. Hans Ziegler, a power expert for the U.S. Army Signal Corps who was sent to Bell Laboratories to evaluate the new device, came to a similar conclusion. After months of extensive discussions, he and his staff found one application in particular where the solar cell made a perfect fit for a top secret program — the development of an artificial satellite.11
Freed from terrestrial restraints on solar radiation — namely, inclement weather and nighttime — “operations above the earth’s atmosphere [would] provide ideal circumstances for solar energy converters,” the Signal Corps believed. Silicon solar cells theoretically would never run out of fuel since they ran on the sun’s energy. The other power option — batteries — would lose their charge in two to three weeks. The modular nature of photovoltaics also meant that cells could be tailored for the exact power requirement of a particular satellite. There would be no wasted weight or bulk. A tiny array could provide the small amount of power that the transistorized communication equipment on board a satellite needed, without encumbering the payload. The Signal Corps concluded, “For longer periods of operation and limited allowance for weight…the photovoltaic principle…appears most promising.”12
The secrecy of America’s space plans ended on July 30, 1955, when President Dwight Eisenhower announced America’s plans to put a satellite into space. A drawing that accompanied Eisenhower’s front-page statement in the New York Times showed that it had a solar power source.13
The civilian scientific panel overseeing America’s space program saw powering satellites with photovoltaics as immensely important, since relying on batteries automatically condemned “most of the on-board apparatus…[to] an active life of only a few weeks.” They noted that “nearly all of the experiments will have enormously greater value if they can be kept operating for several months or more” and decided it was “of utmost importance to have a solar battery system” on board.14
Based on the civilian panel’s recommendations, the Signal Corps was asked to take on the responsibility of designing a solar-cell power system for the program, called Project Vanguard. Its staff readily developed a prototype that clustered individual solar cells on the surface of the satellite’s shell. The group designed the modules to provide “mechanical rigidity against shock and vibration and to comply with thermal requirements of space travel.”15 To test their reliability in space, the Signal Corps attached cell clusters to the nose cones of two high-altitude rockets. One rocket reached an altitude of 126 miles, the second 192 miles, both high enough to experience the vicissitudes of space. “In both firings, the solar cells operated perfectly,” Ziegler reported to an international conference on space activity held in the fall of 1957.16 A U.S. Army Signal Corps press release added, “The power was sufficient for satellite instruments…[and they were] not affected by the temperatures of skin friction as the rockets passed through the atmosphere at more than a mile a second.”17
The Vanguard: The First Practical Use of the Bell Solar Battery
The first satellite with solar cells aboard went into orbit on Saint Patrick’s Day in 1958. Nineteen days later, a headline in the New York Times revealed: “Radio Fails as Chemical Battery Is Exhausted: Solar-Powered Radio Still Functioning.”18 Celebrating the first anniversary of the Vanguard launch, the Signal Corps let the public know that “the sun-powered Vanguard I…is still faithfully sending its radio message back to earth.”19 By July 16, 1958, of the four satellites in the sky only the solar-powered Vanguard and Sputnik III, which was launched after Vanguard and also had solar cells aboard, were still transmitting. The small Vanguard satellite and Sputnik III proved far more valuable to science than the first two Sputniks, equipped with conventional batteries, which had been silenced after a week or so in space.
The success of the Vanguard and subsequent satellites using transistors in tandem with solar batteries demonstrated the synergy between these two newly discovered semiconductor devices. The transistor allowed for miniaturized and long-lived electronics light enough for launchable payloads and reliable enough for an environment where future maintenance was not an option. Because the transistor had a low power draw, the surface of the satellite was sufficient for enough solar cells to provide the necessary electricity, guaranteeing the longevity required for practical space missions.
The success of the United States and Russia with solar cells in space led Soviet space scientist Yevgeniy Fedorov to predict in 1958 that “solar batteries will ultimately become the main source of power in space.”20 Events proved Fedorov right. Those working with satellites came to accept the solar cell as “one of the critically important devices in the space program,” since it “turned out to provide the only practical power source” for satellites within a certain distance from the sun.21 As Rear Admiral Rawson Bennett, chief of naval research, succinctly stated, “The importance of [solar] power is that satellites can play a valuable role in warfare.”22
Solar-powered satellites gave America precise knowledge of its enemies’ capabilities and intentions both on land and in the sky. These satellites could also guide sea-based ICBMs, which became powerful deterrents. The Soviets would no longer consider a knockout first strike, knowing that the United States could retaliate by sea. Another series of solar-powered satellites, called the Vela Hotel, could detect nuclear explosions on the ground and in space. Their verification capability cemented the trust required for signing the nuclear test ban treaty, vital to the health and safety of the planet.23
The urgent demand for solar cells above the earth by the military opened an unexpected and relatively large business for the companies manufacturing them. “On their own commercially, they wouldn’t have gotten anyplace,” observed Dr. Joseph Loferski, who spent a lifetime working in photovoltaics.24 Indeed, as the scientist Martin Wolf contended, “The onset of the Space Age was the salvation of the solar cell industry.”25
John Perlin has written and lectured widely on the history of energy, and solar energy in particular. He’s an analyst in the department of physics, and director for implementation of solar energy and energy efficiency, at his alma mater, the University of California-Santa Barbara.
REFERENCES 1. J. Yellott, “Progress Report: Solar Energy in 1960,” Mechanical Engineering 82 (December 1960): 41.
2. “Power by Sunlight,” Newsweek 46 (October 10, 1955): 108.
3. Daryl Chapin, “The Conversion of Solar Energy to Electrical Power,” May 18, 1956, UCLA lecture notes, 8, courtesy of Mrs. Audrey Chapin Svensson.
4. H. Leslie Hoffman, “Harnessing the Sun’s Energy,” Trusts and Estates 9 (October 1997): 1021.
5. “Converting Atomic Energy Direct into Electricity,” London News 224 (June 12, 1954): 1009.
6. Director of RCA quoted by Dr. Joseph Loferski, research scientist at RCA Laboratories, interview by author.
7. “Converting Atomic Energy Direct into Electricity,” 1009.
8. Martin Wolf, “Notes on the Early History of Solar Cell Development Particularly at National Semiconductor and Hoffman Semiconductor Division,” October 18, 1995, 4, courtesy of Martin Wolf.
9. Daryl Chapin to Robert Ford, letter, AT&T Media Relations, Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, NJ, December 4, 1994, courtesy of Mrs. Aubrey Chapin Svensson.
10. Gordon Raisbeck, “The Solar Battery,” Scientific American (December 1955): 110.
11. Hans Ziegler, “Utilization of Solar Energy,” briefing to Lieutenant General J. O’Connell, September 1955, 9, provided by Dr. Hans Ziegler. The signal corps oversees all power needs of the U.S. Army.
12. Signal Corps Engineering Laboratories, “Proposal for Satellite Program” 1 (top secret report, September 9, 1955), 25–26, courtesy of Dr. Hans Ziegler.
13. “U.S. to Launch History’s First Man-Made- Earth-Circling Satellite,” New York Times, July 30, 1955, 1, 7.
14. “Report of the Working Group on Internal Instrumentation of the USNG/IGY Technical Panel on the Earth Satellite Program” (paper presented at the Conference on Use of Solar Batteries for Powering Satellite Apparatus, Washington, DC, April 30, 1955), James van Allen Papers, Box 251, Folder 7, University of Iowa Archives, Iowa City.
15. Hans Ziegler, “Solar-Power Sources for Satellite Applications,” Annals of the International Geophysical Year (1958): pts. 1–5, 3.3.3, 302–3.
16. Hans Ziegler, “Solar Power for Satellite Applications” (paper presented at the International Geophysical Year Rocket and Science Conference, Washington, DC, September 30–October 5, 1957), provided by Dr. Hans Ziegler.
17. U.S. Army Signal Corps Garrison, Public and Technical Information Division, press release, June 18, 1957, ECOM/Historical Research Collection, Fort Monmouth, NJ.
18. “Radio Fails as Chemical Battery Is Exhausted: Solar-Powered Radio Still Functioning,” New York Times, April 6, 1958, 37.
19. Office of Technical Liaison, Office of the Chief Signal Corps Office, Department of the Army, “Sun-Powered Vanguard I Satellite Marks First Anniversary on March 17, 1959” (Washington, DC, undated), 1, ECOM/Historical Research Collection, Fort Monmouth, NJ.
20. “Reds Boast of Solar Battery,” Electronics, Business Edition, 31 (July 11, 1958): 33.
21. National Research Council, Ad Hoc Panel on Solar Cell Efficiency, Solar Cells’ Outlook for Improved Efficiency (Washington, DC: NRC, 1972), 3.
22. Rawson Bennett, “Navy Energy Needs, Present and Future,” in Proceedings of a Seminar on Advanced Energy Sources and Conversion Techniques…3-7 November, 1958. Sponsored by the U.S. Dept. of Defense, in Cooperation with California Institute of Technology [and] University of California, Los Angeles, under
the Auspices of the U.S. Army Signal Corps
(Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce, Office of Technical Services, [1961?]), 15.
23. Owen Bowen, Fred Kennedy, and Wade Pulliam, DARPA’s Space History, www.monkeypuppet.net/truth/usgovernment/DARPASpaceHistoryFinal.pdf.
24. Loferski, interview.
25. Wolf, “Notes on the Early History of Solar
Cell Development Particularly at National Semiconductor and Hoffman Semiconductor Division,” 7.